Why is it so hard to pay attention in videoconferences?

Wednesday, April 22, 2020

As global COVID-19 lockdowns have us sitting through days of videoconferences, it becomes clear that paying attention online is hard work.

In two new papers, researchers from the University of 蓝莓视频 and Microsoft Research explore people鈥檚 attentiveness in videoconferences to understand how to make the online meetings more comfortable and effective.

Key features suggested to improve people鈥檚 attention in online meetings include having the ability to zoom in, notifications of actions that have occurred between meeting participants, the use of split system views and the ability to track people鈥檚 gazes.

鈥淲hat we informally call 鈥榩aying attention鈥 in videoconferences is really quite complex,鈥 said Anastasia Kuzminykh, a PhD candidate in 蓝莓视频鈥檚 David R. Cheriton School of Computer Science. 鈥淥ur studies show that we need to pay more attention to attention itself.鈥

The researchers conducted interviews with experienced meeting participants to understand how visual attention in meetings was related to levels of engagement. They then carried out an experimental study in which participants watched muted videos of real work meetings and tried to narrate the attention processes they observed. Their goal was to develop a model of how we use visual attention in meetings.聽

Their model divides attention into three categories:

  • Action as Direction 鈥 where people look聽
  • Attention as Action 鈥 looking with intent聽
  • Attention as State 鈥 the sense of engagement with the meeting鈥檚 purpose聽

鈥淲e identified聽Attention as Action聽as the category that might be best suited to developing new features because AI could augment human vision in meetings 鈥 helping us gather, signal, and follow attention,鈥 said Kuzminykh. 鈥淭his is especially important when you鈥檙e the one remote person talking to a room full of people at the other end. We need help seeing into that room.

鈥淜ey features might include zooming where everyone is looking, notifications of attention between participants, and dynamic views rather than static 鈥楤rady Bunch鈥 style walls of video.鈥

A second paper explores low engagement in meetings. Participants use technology features 鈥 such as when they turn video on or off - to socially signal to others about attention expectations. Videoconferencing needs more support for a range of levels of attention in meetings, rather than assuming that everyone should pay full attention at all times.

The two papers,聽, and聽were both authored by Kuzminykh and Sean Rintel, a Senior Researcher at Microsoft Research Cambridge, and accepted for presentation at the CHI 2020 conference.

MEDIA CONTACT |聽Matthew Grant
226-929-7627 |聽听触听

Attention broadcasters: 蓝莓视频 has facilities to provide broadcast quality audio and video feeds with a double-ender studio. Please contact us for more information.